Softball Bat vs Baseball Bat: What’s the Difference?

If you want to play baseball and softball, it’s important to know the difference between the two and the best bats for the respective games.

Softball and baseball bats have several differences. Softball bats are slightly longer than baseball bats. 

However, baseball bats have a thicker bat barrel (barrel diameter) and greater barrel stiffness than softball bats, depending on if you are looking at the static or dynamic stiffness.

Also, baseball bats are usually a bit heavier. They are also different in their construction and elastic properties.

The differences in bats are minor, but if you intend to play professionally, it’s important to know the differences.

Softball is a version of baseball that was invented by baseball players trying to maintain their skills during the long American winters. 

To understand the significant differences between baseball and softball bats, we first have to look at how the games are different. They may appear similar, but they have rules that are poles apart.

Softball vs. Baseball

Softball is basically an easier version of baseball. The most significant difference between softball and baseball is in the pitching styles. 

In softball, pitchers are only allowed to throw the ball underhand, and the ball’s trajectory must have an upward curve. In baseball, pitchers can use overhand throws and side throws.

Other than pitch speed and styles, the softball field is smaller than it is for baseball, which makes it easier to hit home runs and run the bases. 

Softball is traditionally played at a youth level, for example in Little League. Many high school teams play softball too. 

Baseball is generally played by adults at a professional level.

Softball Bats vs. Baseball Bats

Just as the two games are slightly different, softball and baseball bats are also different. The ball sizes, mitts, and bats are all different. 

You also get bats for different types of pitching; for example, adult slow-pitch baseball bats, adult slowpitch softball bats, fastpitch softball bats, as well as youth baseball bats. Adult slow-pitch bats are generally wooden ones.

When playing professionally, the equipment has to follow the rules created by the sports regulatory body. Now let’s get down to the nitty-gritty and see how the baseball and softball bats are different.

What Materials Are Baseball and Softball Bats Made Out Of?

Baseball bats have to be made of wood if they are being used professionally. Softball bats can be made out of wood, aluminum, or carbon fiber. 

So, if someone is playing baseball, they’ll have to use a wooden bat, but if they’re playing softball, then they have more options.

Wood is the classic choice, but wood bats are less durable than other kinds of baseball and softball bats, which is why they are more likely to be damaged by internal friction forces. However, the handle diameter flares out in a wood bat, to try protect it from this.

Wooden bats are ideal as an adult slow pitch bat.

Aluminum baseball and softball bats are smooth. You might prefer aluminum bats to wood ones because they don’t give you splinters. 

They are also the better option as fastpitch bats. The downside, though, is that the bat has less “character.”

Imagine this: You’re shooting the breeze with your teammates and having meaningful conversations. And you point to a bruise on your wood bat, and tell them the story of how it got there. 

With aluminum bats (metal bats), there are no stories because it’s hard to mark an aluminum bat. 

Another factor to consider is the type of game you’ll be playing. If you’re playing slow-pitch softball, you’ll need a slow-pitch softball bat. If you’re playing a fast-pitch softball game, you’ll obviously need a fast-pitch softball bat. 

Often, you’re not allowed to use wood bats in fast-pitch softball and fast-pitch bats are generally lighter; while, in slow-pitch softball, you generally need a heavier bat to compensate for the lack of speed.

Personally, I haven’t used carbon fiber bats (composite bats) much, but some of my teammates swear by them. 

Carbon fiber bats are a recent innovation in softball and baseball bats. The bat is constructed using a carbon fiber polymer (composite). 

They have better durability than wood bats and aluminum; plus, they have better weight distribution, bat speed, and the added bonus of the trampoline effect (the bounce-back of an aluminum bat), which make them ideal for adult baseball games.

The biggest downside to carbon fiber bats is that they are much more expensive than other bats; however, they are much more durable. 

Although they are permissible in some adult baseball leagues, they are not allowed on the youth level. Little League has actually banned composite material bats and deemed them unsuitable as youth bats because of the ball speed and trampoline effect.

If I were to give my honest opinion, I’d choose wood bats over others any day. Nothing beats the classic look of a wood bat. 

However, if there’s a big game coming up, then I reluctantly hang up my old wood bat and take out the aluminum one. Because, regardless of my feelings, I’ve found that aluminum bats help you hit a harder ball.

Differences in Bat Lengths

When I place my adult softball bats and baseball bats side by side, the most obvious difference I see is in their length. Baseball bats have a slightly shorter total length (one inch) than softball bats. 

If you go to a sports shop, you can buy both types of bats in different lengths.

If I’m playing with friends, then I don’t care what bat I use. But when I’m playing for my official adult baseball team, then I ensure the length is right. 

The most commonly used length of a bat for softball is 34-inches long, but for baseball, I use a shorter bat that’s 33 inches in length.

Differences in Bat Weight 

Baseball bats have a heavier weight than softball bats. The difference makes sense because softball is meant to be an easier game. 

A bat’s weight is determined from the difference between the length and drop of the bat—the drop weight. But how light or heavy the bat feels also depends on the bat’s balance point (center of gravity).

If you use a bat that weighs less, then it’s much easier to swing. Bats made out of aluminum or carbon fiber are much lighter than their wooden counterparts.

But the problem with having a light bat is that you have less actual weight in your swing. 

It’s easier to connect with the ball from a slow pitch when you swing the lighter softball bat, but the swing has less power. So, it’s harder to hit home runs.

What it boils down to is that using a softball bat means more hits. But with the baseball bat, even though I get fewer hits, every hit is more powerful and harder to field.

All in all, baseball bats are good for high-risk, high-reward situations. But, if I’m looking to play a more consistent adult baseball game, then I pick up my softball bat.

Differences in Barrel Diameter

The other noticeable difference is that one has a thicker head than the other. Officially, this is called the “barrel diameters” of the bat.

Sidenote: Softball bats tend to have larger barrel diameters than baseball bats. 

The bat length can be divided into three sections – the handle, the taper, and the barrel. 

The handle is where you grip the bat; after that is the taper section, where the bat becomes thicker. Finally, there’s the barrel section, which is the thickest part of the bat.

Bats that are used for fast pitches are made with a barrel that comprises almost half the length of the bat.

The barrel section is what is known as the head of the bat; ideally, this is where the ball should connect with the bat to give the best possible hit.

As softball bats have a thicker barrel and generally the same diameter all the way, it means there’s more area for the ball to connect with. So, when I’m thrown a slow pitch, it’s easier to hit if I use a softball bat. 

Adult baseball bats have narrower diameters, so connecting with the ball becomes more difficult.

The Verdict

To sum it up, softball bats can be made of wood, aluminum, or carbon fiber, while official baseball bats can only be made of wood. Wood bats are also generally considered the best “youth bats.” 

The different bats also have different degrees of barrel stiffness. 

Softball bats are lighter, longer, and have thicker barrels, which means it’s easier to play using a softball bat. However, if you want to bat faster, use a baseball bat.

It’s important to use the right bat for the right game.  that is permitted by whichever sporting body makes the rules for your team. I always try to find out what the rules are for an upcoming game before I make a decision about which bat I will use.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use my softball bat at a baseball game?

That depends on whether you’re just playing with friends or if you’re going to be playing an official match. If I’m playing with friends, we take a vote and decide for ourselves.

But if we’re playing an official match, we have to ensure we use the right bat. We have to use adult baseball bats that conform to the rules of the sports authority officiating the match. 

So, find out what the rules are so you can follow them. Take note that Little League requirements are different to adult and high school rules. 

Are baseball bats better than softball bats?

In my experience, I’ve found that softball bats increase the chances that I’ll hit a pitch. But if I want to hit harder and be considered a “power hitter,” then baseball bats are better. 

I’ll get fewer hits with a baseball bat, but thanks to the length of the bat and, sometimes, the trampoline effect, there is a greater chance that I’ll hit the ball farther and faster than I can with a softball bat.

Aside from performance, softball bats may be considered “kids’ bats” by more experienced players. So, if you’re playing with experienced players and you don’t want to be laughed at, it’s better to use your baseball bat.

Is it easier to play with a softball bat than a baseball bat?

Softball bats are lighter and longer than baseball bats, which means that it’s easier to swing them. I’ve found that using softball bats requires less strength and stamina than baseball bats. 

Softball bats also have a thicker barrel, which makes it easier to connect with a fast pitch, and, for some people, a heavy bat like a basketball bat is harder to play with.